Removing Private Mortgage Insurance: PMI Cancellation Guide

Want to see what you qualify for? I can run your numbers and give you a clear answer quickly.

Removing Private Mortgage Insurance: PMI Cancellation Guide

Private mortgage insurance can make homeownership possible with a smaller down payment.

But it does not necessarily need to remain for the life of a conventional mortgage.

Removing private mortgage insurance may reduce your monthly payment without requiring you to sell the home or pay off the entire loan.

Depending on your mortgage, PMI may be removed through:

Borrower-requested cancellation based on the original property value.
Automatic termination under federal law.
Cancellation based on the property’s current value.
A substantial principal payment.
Home improvements that increased the property’s value.
Refinancing into a new mortgage without PMI.
Reaching the midpoint of the original amortization schedule.

The correct strategy depends on:

Current loan balance.
Original property value.
Current property value.
Mortgage age.
Payment history.
Property type.
Occupancy.
Mortgage investor.
Existing interest rate.
Cost of a new valuation.
Current refinance rates.

Private mortgage insurance should not be confused with FHA mortgage insurance or the USDA annual fee.

Those programs have different rules.

What Is Private Mortgage Insurance?

Private mortgage insurance, commonly called PMI, is insurance associated with certain conventional mortgages.

It protects the mortgage lender or investor—not the homeowner—if the borrower defaults.

PMI is commonly required when a conventional borrower makes a down payment of less than 20%.

The amount may depend on:

Loan-to-value ratio.
Credit score.
Loan program.
Property type.
Occupancy.
Number of borrowers.
Debt-to-income ratio.
Mortgage term.
Fixed or adjustable rate.
Mortgage-insurance provider.
Coverage level required by the investor.

PMI can allow a buyer to purchase before accumulating a 20% down payment.

Related resources: Should You Put 20% Down? and Conventional 97 and 3% Down Mortgage Guide.

Why Removing Private Mortgage Insurance Matters

Removing PMI may lower the required mortgage payment without changing:

Interest rate.
Remaining loan term.
Mortgage balance.
Mortgage servicer.
Borrowers obligated on the loan.
Existing favorable loan terms.

For example:

Monthly PMI: $225
Remaining expected PMI period: 36 months
Potential future cost: $8,100

If the mortgage qualifies for cancellation today, removing PMI could avoid some or all of that remaining expense.

However, cancellation is not automatic merely because the homeowner believes the property has 20% equity.

The applicable requirements must be satisfied.

PMI vs. FHA Mortgage Insurance

PMI applies to conventional mortgages.

FHA loans use mortgage insurance premiums, commonly called MIP.

FHA mortgage insurance may include:

An upfront mortgage insurance premium.
An annual premium paid monthly.

FHA MIP cancellation depends on the loan’s origination date, original loan-to-value ratio, and term.

For many FHA mortgages with case numbers assigned on or after June 3, 2013:

An original loan-to-value ratio of 90% or less generally results in annual MIP for 11 years.
An original loan-to-value ratio above 90% generally results in annual MIP for the mortgage term.

Paying the FHA balance below 80% does not generally eliminate lifetime MIP.

Refinancing into a conventional mortgage may be necessary to remove it.

Related resource: FHA Mortgage Insurance Explained.

PMI vs. USDA Annual Fees

USDA loans use an upfront guarantee fee and an annual fee rather than conventional PMI.

The annual fee is typically paid as part of the monthly mortgage payment.

It is governed by USDA program rules and is not canceled under the conventional PMI rules discussed in this guide.

A USDA borrower seeking to eliminate the annual fee may need to refinance into another mortgage program.

Related resources: USDA Loan Eligibility Requirements and USDA Income Limits Explained.

Does a VA Loan Have PMI?

VA loans do not require monthly private mortgage insurance.

An eligible veteran may finance a home without a down payment and without monthly PMI.

The VA funding fee is a separate program charge and is not monthly mortgage insurance.

Some veterans may be exempt from the funding fee based on qualifying circumstances.

The Four Primary Ways Conventional PMI Ends

Conventional PMI can generally end through:

Borrower-requested cancellation based on original value.
Automatic termination at the scheduled 78% threshold.
Final termination at the midpoint of the amortization schedule.
Investor-approved cancellation based on current property value.

Each path has different requirements.

Borrower-Requested PMI Cancellation at 80%

For many covered conventional mortgages, a homeowner may request PMI cancellation when the principal balance is scheduled to reach 80% of the property’s original value.

A borrower may also reach the 80% threshold early by making additional principal payments.

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau explains that the servicer generally must approve an eligible request when:

The request is made in writing.
The loan is current.
The borrower has a good payment history.
There are no disqualifying subordinate liens.
The borrower provides requested evidence that the property’s value has not declined below its original value.

The PMI disclosure provided at closing may identify the first scheduled date on which cancellation can be requested.

What Does Original Value Mean?

For a home purchase, original value generally means the lower of:

Purchase price.
Original appraised value.

For a refinance, original value generally means the appraised or accepted property value used for that refinance.

Example:

Purchase price: $500,000
Original appraisal: $510,000
Original value for PMI purposes: $500,000
80% of original value: $400,000
78% of original value: $390,000

The borrower may generally request eligible cancellation when the balance reaches $400,000.

Automatic termination would generally be based on the scheduled date the balance reaches $390,000, assuming the mortgage and property are covered and the loan is current.

Can Additional Principal Payments Remove PMI Sooner?

Yes, for many conventional mortgages.

If additional principal payments reduce the balance to 80% of the original value, the homeowner may be able to request cancellation earlier than the original schedule.

For example:

Original value: $500,000
80% threshold: $400,000
Current mortgage balance: $420,000
Additional principal required to reach 80%: $20,000

After applying the $20,000 principal payment, the borrower could request PMI cancellation.

The servicer may still require:

Written request.
Acceptable payment history.
Confirmation that no disqualifying subordinate liens exist.
Property-value verification.
Satisfaction of investor requirements.

Do not make a large principal payment solely to remove PMI until the servicer provides the cancellation requirements in writing.

Text a Question

If you want help walking through your specific situation, I can run the numbers with you.

Get Pre-Approved

Automatic PMI Termination at 78%

For many covered conventional mortgages, PMI must automatically terminate when the principal balance is scheduled to reach 78% of the original property value.

The calculation is based on the original amortization schedule—not the property’s current market value.

The mortgage must generally be current on the termination date.

If the loan is not current, automatic termination may be delayed until the payments are brought current.

The homeowner does not normally need to request this automatic termination.

Automatic termination is based on the scheduled balance, even if additional payments caused the actual balance to reach 78% earlier.

When additional payments reduce the balance early, borrower-requested cancellation at the applicable 80% threshold is usually the relevant process.

Final PMI Termination at the Loan Midpoint

PMI may also be required to end after the mortgage reaches the midpoint of its original amortization period, assuming the loan is current.

For a 30-year mortgage, the midpoint is generally reached after 15 years.

This provision is particularly relevant for mortgages where the balance does not reach 78% before the midpoint, such as certain:

Interest-only loans.
Balloon mortgages.
Loans with principal forbearance.
Modified mortgages.
Unusual amortization structures.

Midpoint termination does not normally require the property to have 22% equity.

It is based on the original amortization period and applicable federal requirements.

Removing PMI Based on Current Property Value

A homeowner may have enough equity for early PMI cancellation because the property appreciated after purchase.

Potential appreciation may come from:

General market growth.
Neighborhood development.
New construction nearby.
Limited housing inventory.
Property improvements.
Additional square footage.
Kitchen or bathroom renovation.
Major modernization.
Conversion of unfinished space.
Other marketable improvements.

Cancellation based on current value is generally governed by the mortgage investor’s requirements rather than only the basic federal 80% original-value rule.

The homeowner must request the review.

The servicer will determine the required valuation method.

Fannie Mae PMI Cancellation Based on Current Value

Current Fannie Mae servicing guidance generally requires the following loan-to-value ratios for a one-unit primary residence or second home:

75% or less when the mortgage is between two and five years old.
80% or less when the mortgage is more than five years old.

Fannie Mae generally requires at least two years of seasoning before current-value cancellation.

That minimum seasoning may be waived when borrower-completed property improvements materially increased the value. In that situation, the loan-to-value ratio generally must be 80% or less.

The borrower must also have an acceptable payment history.

Current Fannie Mae guidance generally requires:

Loan current when cancellation is requested.
No payment 30 or more days late during the previous 12 months.
No payment 60 or more days late during the previous 24 months.

The requirements may differ for investment properties, two-to-four-unit primary residences, assumed mortgages, modified loans, and other circumstances.

The full Fannie Mae mortgage-insurance termination guidance should be applied by the servicer.

Current-Value PMI Example

Assume:

Original purchase price: $500,000
Original mortgage: $475,000
Current mortgage balance: $440,000
Mortgage age: Three years
Current appraised value: $600,000

The current loan-to-value ratio is:

$440,000 ÷ $600,000 = 73.3%

The balance is still 88% of the original $500,000 value, so the loan has not reached the original-value cancellation threshold.

However, the current loan-to-value ratio is below 75%.

If the mortgage is Fannie Mae-owned and all current-value cancellation requirements are satisfied, the homeowner may qualify to remove PMI based on appreciation.

How Property Improvements Can Affect PMI Removal

Substantial improvements may support an early current-value cancellation request.

Possible qualifying improvements may include:

Adding square footage.
Completing a major kitchen renovation.
Renovating bathrooms.
Adding a bedroom or bathroom.
Converting previously unfinished space.
Replacing major systems as part of a comprehensive renovation.
Completing improvements that materially increase marketability and useful life.

Routine maintenance may not qualify as a substantial improvement.

Examples may include:

Interior painting.
Minor repairs.
Replacing worn carpet.
Lawn maintenance.
Fixing a leaking faucet.
Replacing an appliance.
Ordinary upkeep.

The servicer decides whether the improvement and valuation satisfy the investor’s requirements.

Save:

Contracts.
Invoices.
Receipts.
Permits.
Before-and-after photographs.
Completion certificates.
Plans or specifications.

Related resource: Financing a Home With an Unfinished Addition.

Who Orders the PMI Valuation?

The mortgage servicer generally controls the valuation process for PMI cancellation.

The homeowner should not independently order an appraisal and assume the servicer will accept it.

Depending on the investor and circumstances, the servicer may require:

Automated valuation model.
Broker price opinion.
Drive-by valuation.
Interior and exterior property valuation.
Full appraisal.
Another investor-approved method.

The borrower may be responsible for the valuation cost.

Before paying for a valuation, ask the servicer:

Which valuation is required?
Who will order it?
How much will it cost?
Is the fee refundable?
What value or loan-to-value ratio is required?
What happens if the value is insufficient?
When can another request be made?

Can Your Own Market Analysis Remove PMI?

A real estate agent’s comparative market analysis may help estimate whether a formal cancellation request is worthwhile.

However, it generally does not replace the valuation required by the mortgage servicer.

Online home-value estimates also may not be sufficient.

The official decision is based on the investor-approved valuation obtained through the servicer’s process.

How to Calculate Your Current Loan-to-Value Ratio

Use this formula:

Current mortgage balance ÷ current property value = current LTV

For example:

Mortgage balance: $360,000
Estimated property value: $480,000

$360,000 ÷ $480,000 = 75% LTV

Remember that an estimated property value is not necessarily the value the servicer will accept.

The official valuation may be higher or lower.

Does a Second Mortgage Affect PMI Cancellation?

It can.

A HELOC or closed-end second mortgage may affect eligibility because the servicer may evaluate whether another lien exists against the property.

For original-value cancellation under federal standards, the borrower may need to certify that there are no junior liens.

Investor rules may also consider:

Combined loan-to-value ratio.
Home-equity line limit.
Outstanding HELOC balance.
Lien priority.
Property value.

A homeowner should disclose all subordinate financing when requesting PMI cancellation.

Related resources: Closed-End Second Mortgage Guide and HELOC vs. Closed-End Second Mortgage.

Does a Mortgage Recast Remove PMI?

Not automatically.

A mortgage recast recalculates the required payment after a substantial principal reduction.

The reduced balance may help the homeowner reach a PMI cancellation threshold, but cancellation remains a separate process.

The homeowner may need to:

Request PMI removal.
Provide written certification.
Document payment history.
Pay for an approved valuation.
Confirm subordinate liens.
Satisfy investor requirements.

Related resource: Mortgage Recast vs. Refinance.

Can Refinancing Remove PMI?

Yes.

A homeowner may refinance into a new conventional mortgage without PMI when the new loan-to-value ratio and program requirements permit it.

For example:

Current mortgage balance: $400,000
Current property value: $525,000
New refinance loan: $405,000
Estimated LTV: 77.1%

The new loan may not require conventional PMI.

However, refinancing involves:

New interest rate.
Closing costs.
New loan term.
Appraisal or valuation.
Credit qualification.
Income verification.
Title work.
Potential term reset.
New mortgage balance.

Removing PMI does not automatically justify refinancing.

Related resources: Rate-and-Term Refinance Guide and Refinance Break-Even Analysis.

PMI Cancellation vs. Refinancing

Requesting cancellation may be stronger when:

The existing mortgage has a favorable rate.
The loan qualifies for cancellation.
The servicer’s valuation cost is reasonable.
No borrower needs to be added or removed.
The existing term remains appropriate.
The homeowner does not need cash.
Refinance rates are higher.

Refinancing may be stronger when:

The current loan cannot cancel mortgage insurance.
The mortgage is FHA with long-term or lifetime MIP.
Current rates are meaningfully lower.
The borrower wants a different term.
A borrower must be removed.
The homeowner wants to change loan programs.
The refinance provides additional financial benefits.
The savings justify the closing costs.

PMI Cancellation Cost Example

Assume:

Monthly PMI: $200
Servicer-required valuation: $250
Expected remaining ownership period: Four years
Potential PMI savings: $9,600
Valuation cost: $250

If cancellation is approved, the cost may be recovered in approximately:

$250 ÷ $200 = 1.25 months

The request may be worthwhile.

However, if the value comes in below the required threshold, PMI may remain and the valuation fee may not be refunded.

Refinance-to-Remove-PMI Example

Assume:

Monthly PMI savings: $200
Principal-and-interest savings: $150
Total monthly savings: $350
True refinance costs: $7,000

The simple break-even period is:

$7,000 ÷ $350 = 20 months

If the homeowner expects to keep the new mortgage for significantly longer than 20 months, the refinance may be beneficial.

The analysis should still compare the new loan balance, term, and principal reduction.

Related resource: Refinance Closing Costs Explained.

What If the Existing Rate Is Lower Than Current Rates?

Refinancing solely to remove PMI may be counterproductive when the existing interest rate is substantially lower than current refinance rates.

The PMI savings could be offset by a higher principal-and-interest payment.

In that situation, the homeowner should first investigate:

Original-value cancellation.
Current-value cancellation.
Principal reduction.
Property-improvement exception.
Waiting until the next eligible cancellation date.
Mortgage recast combined with a cancellation request.

Preserving a favorable mortgage rate may be more valuable than immediately removing PMI.

Lender-Paid Mortgage Insurance

Some conventional mortgages use lender-paid mortgage insurance.

The borrower may not see a separate monthly PMI charge because the cost is incorporated into the mortgage pricing or interest rate.

Lender-paid mortgage insurance usually cannot be removed from the monthly payment in the same way as borrower-paid PMI.

Refinancing may be required to replace the loan structure.

The homeowner should review the original Loan Estimate, Closing Disclosure, and mortgage-insurance disclosures.

Related resource: Loan Estimate Explained.

Single-Premium Mortgage Insurance

A borrower may have paid mortgage insurance through:

An upfront single premium.
A financed single premium.
A combination of upfront and monthly premiums.

Canceling the insurance may not reduce the monthly payment if no monthly premium is being collected.

Refund eligibility depends on:

Mortgage-insurance policy.
Loan age.
Cancellation method.
Whether the premium was refundable.
Mortgage-insurance provider.
Investor requirements.

The servicer and mortgage insurer should be consulted before assuming a refund will be available.

Does PMI Removal Lower the Payment Immediately?

The payment should be reduced after the servicer formally terminates the mortgage insurance.

The exact effective date and escrow adjustment can vary.

Fannie Mae servicing guidance states that the servicer must reduce the payment by the amount collected for mortgage insurance within the required timeframe and notify the borrower after termination.

However, the total payment may not decrease by exactly the former PMI amount if the servicer simultaneously performs an escrow analysis and:

Property taxes increased.
Homeowners-insurance premiums increased.
An escrow shortage exists.
Other escrow requirements changed.

Related resource: Why Payments Increase After Closing.

What If the Servicer Denies the PMI Request?

The servicer should explain why the request was denied.

Possible reasons include:

Insufficient equity.
Property value below the required amount.
Loan has not satisfied seasoning.
Recent late payments.
Outstanding subordinate financing.
Ineligible property type.
Mortgage not covered by the requested cancellation rule.
Loan modification.
Incomplete documentation.
Valuation did not meet investor requirements.
Mortgage is FHA, USDA, or another non-PMI structure.

After a denial, ask:

Which requirement was not satisfied?
What value was used?
What loan-to-value ratio was calculated?
When can a new request be submitted?
Can the balance be paid down?
Can another approved valuation be requested?
Does the investor permit an appeal?
Is cancellation available under a different method?

Keep copies of all correspondence.

How to Find Out Who Owns the Mortgage

PMI cancellation rules may depend on whether the mortgage is owned by:

Fannie Mae.
Freddie Mac.
A private investor.
A bank or credit union.
Another institution.

The mortgage servicer collects payments but may not own the loan.

Homeowners may use the official Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac loan-lookup tools or ask the servicer to identify the applicable investor and PMI-cancellation standards.

Does Loan Modification Affect PMI Removal?

It can.

A modified mortgage may have:

A new amortization schedule.
Deferred principal.
Changed maturity date.
Capitalized arrearages.
Revised payment history.
Special investor requirements.

PMI termination may be evaluated using the modified loan’s terms and applicable law.

The homeowner should provide the complete modification agreement when requesting a review.

Does Forbearance Affect PMI Cancellation?

Forbearance can affect the payment-history requirement.

The servicer may consider:

Whether payments became delinquent.
Whether missed payments were deferred.
Whether a modification occurred.
Whether the borrower completed a repayment plan.
Whether the loan is currently paid as agreed.
Investor disaster or hardship exceptions.

A loan being current today does not always mean the payment history satisfies borrower-requested cancellation requirements.

PMI on Investment Properties and Multifamily Homes

PMI cancellation rules can be more restrictive for:

Investment properties.
Two-to-four-unit primary residences.
Second homes.
Properties with subordinate financing.

For example, current Fannie Mae guidance generally requires a 70% loan-to-value ratio for borrower-requested original-value cancellation on:

One-to-four-unit investment properties.
Two-to-four-unit principal residences.

Current-value cancellation for these properties generally has separate seasoning and valuation requirements.

Do not apply the standard one-unit primary-residence 80% rule to every property type.

Related resource: Two-to-Four-Unit Property Mortgage Guide.

Real PMI Removal Scenarios

The Original-Value Scenario

A homeowner purchased for $500,000 with a $475,000 mortgage.

Additional principal payments reduce the balance to $400,000.

The borrower requests cancellation based on 80% of the original value and satisfies the payment-history, valuation, and lien requirements.

The Appreciation Scenario

A homeowner purchased three years ago.

The mortgage balance remains above 80% of the original purchase price, but market appreciation reduces the current LTV to 74%.

The servicer orders an approved valuation and evaluates the request under the investor’s current-value cancellation rules.

The Improvement Scenario

A borrower completes a major addition and kitchen renovation within two years of purchasing the property.

The increased value brings the current LTV below 80%.

The borrower provides improvement documentation and requests a waiver of the normal seasoning requirement under applicable investor guidelines.

The FHA Scenario

A homeowner’s FHA balance falls below 80% of the current property value.

The borrower assumes mortgage insurance will automatically end.

Because the loan’s annual MIP is governed by FHA rules rather than conventional PMI rules, refinancing may be required to remove it.

The Low-Rate Scenario

A homeowner has a 3.25% conventional mortgage with $175 of monthly PMI.

Current refinance rates are substantially higher.

The homeowner requests current-value PMI cancellation instead of giving up the favorable existing rate.

The Second-Lien Scenario

A homeowner has sufficient first-mortgage equity but also has an open HELOC.

The servicer reviews the subordinate lien and combined leverage before approving PMI cancellation.

Common Misconceptions

“PMI Automatically Ends When My Home Appreciates.”

Automatic termination is generally based on the original value and scheduled amortization.

The homeowner must request cancellation based on current value.

“PMI Ends the Moment My Balance Reaches 80%.”

The borrower generally must request cancellation and satisfy the applicable requirements.

Automatic termination usually occurs at the scheduled 78% threshold.

“Every Appraisal Can Be Used to Remove PMI.”

The mortgage servicer normally controls the valuation process and may not accept an appraisal ordered independently.

“FHA Mortgage Insurance Is PMI.”

FHA MIP follows different cancellation rules.

“A Recast Automatically Removes PMI.”

A recast and PMI cancellation are separate servicing actions.

“Opening a HELOC Will Not Matter.”

A subordinate lien may affect PMI-cancellation eligibility.

“Refinancing Is Always the Best Way to Remove PMI.”

Refinancing can create closing costs, a new interest rate, and a new amortization schedule.

Requesting cancellation on the existing loan may be significantly less expensive.

“Home Maintenance Counts as a Substantial Improvement.”

Ordinary repairs and upkeep may not qualify for an improvement-based seasoning exception.

Questions to Ask the Mortgage Servicer

When requesting PMI removal, ask:

Is this conventional PMI or another type of mortgage insurance?
Who owns my mortgage?
What is the original value used for cancellation?
What is my current principal balance?
When is my scheduled 80% cancellation date?
When is the automatic 78% termination date?
Can I cancel based on current value?
What seasoning requirement applies?
What LTV is required?
Does my payment history qualify?
How does my HELOC or second mortgage affect the request?
What valuation is required?
Who orders the valuation?
What does it cost?
Are my improvements sufficient for an exception?
What documents should I provide?
When will the payment change?
What appeal or reconsideration process is available?

Real Lender Perspective

Before refinancing to eliminate mortgage insurance, determine whether it can be removed from the existing loan.

That should usually be the first step.

A homeowner may already have:

A favorable interest rate.
A partially amortized mortgage.
Minimal remaining closing costs to recover.
An eligible current-value cancellation option.

Replacing that loan solely to eliminate a relatively small PMI payment may produce a worse financial result if current rates are higher.

On the other hand, refinancing may be appropriate when:

The current loan is FHA with long-term MIP.
Market rates are favorable.
The borrower wants a different term.
A borrower must be removed.
The new loan provides multiple benefits.
The closing costs can be recovered.

The proper question is not simply:

“How do I get rid of mortgage insurance?”

It is:

“Which method removes the insurance while creating the strongest overall mortgage position?”

Who This Guide Is For

This guide may be especially helpful for:

Conventional borrowers with monthly PMI.
Homeowners whose property value has increased.
Borrowers who made additional principal payments.
Homeowners who completed major renovations.
FHA borrowers considering conventional refinancing.
Homeowners with low existing mortgage rates.
Borrowers with a second mortgage or HELOC.
Homeowners considering a mortgage recast.
Buyers who originally made a small down payment.
Investment-property owners with mortgage insurance.
Two-to-four-unit property owners.
Homeowners trying to reduce their monthly payment.

Final Thoughts

Removing private mortgage insurance can reduce the monthly payment without replacing an otherwise favorable conventional mortgage.

The primary options include:

Requesting cancellation when the balance reaches 80% of original value.
Waiting for automatic termination at the scheduled 78% threshold.
Reaching final termination at the amortization midpoint.
Requesting cancellation based on current value.
Documenting substantial property improvements.
Making an additional principal payment.
Refinancing into a loan without mortgage insurance.

The correct process depends on the mortgage investor, property type, payment history, seasoning, property value, and subordinate liens.

Before refinancing, contact the current servicer and request the exact PMI-cancellation requirements in writing.

The least expensive solution may be a valuation and cancellation request—not an entirely new mortgage.